268 State Highway 7 Sidney, NY 13838 607-563-1522

Read Our Reviews For Top Rated Dealer In Sidney, NY

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Page: 1 of 28 (271 reviews)

Sort By:
Per Page:

Steelersteel

01/16/2026
5.00

Brooke Hayes did a fantastic job helping buy a new truck! Had a lot of trouble getting everything finalized, and she help the whole way

Mari Ruff

01/16/2026
5.00

Worked with Brandan Collins and he is Amazing !!!!! Bought an HRV 😀 am very happy , Thank you Brandan for all your help and understanding!!!!! Great job

Valerie Tompkins

01/16/2026
5.00

I was very weary of buying another jeep as my past experience was not very good. Brooke worked with me even on her days off to find me the car that I would be happy with. She was attentive, patient, kind and very dedicated. She made the process simple and quick and did not give up until she found me something that worked for my budget and also something I would be happy with! Thank you Brooke for going above and beyond and doing everything you did to put me in a reliable vehicle. I appreciate you for all you did and do and I would recommend Butlers, 10/10.

Michael Nodine

01/15/2026
5.00

Brandan at butler auto was amazing to work with easy going transparent and honest they got me an amazing deal on my 2021 Subaru Impreza I am a very satisfied customer will definitely go back for my next vehicle

Hanna Whitman

01/14/2026
5.00

My experience as a first time buyer was exceptional. Brooke made me feel very welcomed. Explained everything wonderfully. Highly recommend, Brooke!

Cindy Donaldson

01/12/2026
5.00

Our experience at Butler auto has always been great! Quick, efficient and friendly service.

Tiffany Cinar

01/10/2026
5.00

Dale R Sparlin

01/09/2026
5.00

My wife and I knew instantly when Brooke Hayes came out to greet us that we were in good hands. She was engaging, and listened fully to what we were looking for. Through the entire process, Brooke was attentive to every detail, seeking our reactions and carrying on pleasant social exchanges, all without a hint of "salesman" attitude. Her flexibility was amazing: the day of closing, my wife had an appointment in a nearby city. It never occurred to us that she would be needed to sign paperwork. Brooke handled all this with grace, going ahead with what could be done, then staying engaged until my wife could return. All without the slightest impatience. She has continued to stay in contact, wanting to be certain all was well with our car, encouraging us to let her know of any needs or concerns.

Haley Aldrich

01/07/2026
5.00

Scott T. was very easy to work with! Would definitely recommend working with him!

john cammarata

01/06/2026
5.00

Brooke was extremely helpful and pleasant to work with, the service was also extremely helpful. Would definitely buy from Butler Auto again!

Page: 1 of 28 (271 reviews)

Text Us